Live
in The Banjar
Source: Bali
Echo, photos by Arie
Basoeki.
One
afternoon. A group of children are
playing in a building with a dirt
floor. Some of them are running
around, some of them are crowded
around a chess board, and others
are sitting on a long wooden bench.
At another end of the building,
a group of old men are chatting,
each holding their prize fighting
cocks. They are talking about the
taien (cock fight). While
the men chat, the cocks begin to
crow, one after another, stirring
up a great clamour. In another corner
of the building some old trader
women are busy selling peanuts,
ruick, tipat and Balinese
cakes. Such is a typical afternoon
in the bonjor hall of Bukit
Jangkrik, about 3 kilometers from
Gianyar. The same kind of scene
can be seen in bonjors all
over Bali. So, what is a bonjor
exactly? Wayan Suardika explains.
BANJAR
It could be argued that there
is no real urban Bali. What appear
as cities are really just collections
of banjars - small communities
bound by religion and a local
brand of communalism. As a lembaga
adat - a 'traditional institution'
- the banjar is ideally
autonomous of the state and functions
primarily to serve its members
communal and religious needs.
The ba7zjar's manifold functions
are expressed in the various activities
that take place in the banjar
hall, which serves as a recreational
space for children and teenagers,
a place where dance and gamelan
classes are held, trading
takes place, and cock fights proceed.
The banjar administration
is also responsible for matters
of a religious nature, such as
weddings and temple ceremonies.
Officially,
the banjar has complete
autonomy and all matters relating
to the banjar administration
and the community it serves should
ideally require the agreement
of the kelihan banjar, the
head of the banjar, in
order to proceed. But in the real
world, the banjar is well-integrated
into the affairs of state - a
rather unavoidable predicament
considering that the banjar
is the most basic building
block of the whole of Balinese
society. For example, development
programs are destined to fail
if they lack support at the banjar
level. The banjar, therefore,
is the most important link between
the government and the Balinese
people. Bali's banjars are
like tiny screws in a huge engine.
If one of the screws comes loose,
the whole engine will start to
fail.
The
resignation of fomer President
Suharto on 21 May, 1998, signalled
Indonesia's official entry into
the so-called ika of Reform.
The word reformasi has
since come into daily use it has
become the rationale and driving
force of just about everything
taking place across the nation.
As nationhood is being redefined,
reformasi goes right to
the heart of common Indonesians'
everyday lives.- The above mentioried
engine is, in other words,
currently being reserviced, thus
begging the question: what is
to become of the screws that hold
it together? As the reform fever
is rapidly infecting Indonesian
society at large, what are the
implications of this for the Balinese
banjar and the way it has
hitherto been organised? Considering
the banjar's role in esuring
social cohesion in Bali, how are
such traditional institutions
in Bali such as the banjar
taking part in the social
and cultural changes that are
currently underway?
Most
Balinese I spoke to in preparing
this piece hold few fears that
the changes the country is now
undergoing threaten the existence
of Bali's banjar per se.
After all, the banjar has
survived and adapted to many changes
over the past thirty years - the
implementation of new development
programs, new security measures,
the influx of foreign cultures
and values via tourism, the use
of its land for construction projects.
etc. But simply continuing
to exist, many assert, is not
the issue. The matter at hand
is how to bolster the authority
of the banjar as a traditional
insitution vis-a-vis that of the
state.
STRUCTURE
At
the head of the banjar is the
kelihan dinas, who represents
the banjar to the sub-district
and district-level branches of
government. Anything to do with
(civil) administrative matters
of state - such as obtaining the
various documents needed for job
applications, school enrolments,
passport applications, identity
cards, 'good behaviour' cards,
birth certificates, school certificates
and family registers is the domain
of the kelihan dinas. The
term of the kelihan dinas is
vague, and in many cases the post
in held indefinitely by one person.
The
post of the kelihan adat, the
'traditional' banjar head,
is officially parallel - neither
above nor below - to that of the
kelihan dinas. The kelihan
adat is responsible for all
matters of a 'traditional' nature,
such as weddings, temple ceremonies,
and what and what may not be done
according to tradition. The term
of a kelihan adat is usually
five years, but it depends on
the banjar in question
whether a kelihan adat may
serve two terms or not. "The
kelihan dinas can sometimes
double as the kelian adat,"
says Bukit Jangkrik's kelihan
dinas, 1 Made Supraptha. "It
depends on the will of the banjar
members."
The
banjar also includes several
community groups, such as the
PKK (Pembinaan Kesejahteraan
KeIuarga: Maintenance of Family
Welfare) and the STT (Sekehe
Teruna-Teruni: youth group).
In the name of 'women's development',
the New Order government established
PKK all over Indonesia, and it
was in the seventies that the
institution became integrated
into Bali's banjars. Its
main activities are sewing and
cooking classes. Whilst it falls
under the auspices of the banjar,
the PKK is not strictly a
traditional Balinese community
organisation. It is a development
institution molded in the New
Order style.
Like
the PKK, the STT is also often
made responsible for implementing
development programs - in this
case ones that relate to youth.
The majority of STTS, however,
are most active at Galungan, the
Hindu festive day which falls
every six months, when they convene
bazaars to raise funds for community
coffers.
In
addition, each banjar has
at least one subak, which
is responsible for regulating
agricultural matters such as irrigation
and harvesting. The head of
the subak is called a pekaseh,
whose responsiblity is to
regulate the flow of irrigation
water, and ensure every paddy
gets and equal share.
It
is obligatory for each banjar
to have an awig-awig, or
a constitution. Based on traditional
law, as opposed to state law,
the awig-awig regulates the activities
of the banjar and its members.
Awig-awig vary according
to banjar, but according to Made
Alon, Panti Cede's kelihan
banjar: "There are many
similarities in the awig-awig
of banjar in close proximity
with one another.
ADAPTATION
Whilst
a common assumption is that the
Era of Reform has ushered in greater
democracy, many sources believe
that the banjar has been
reforming itself for generations,
and that the most visible changes
the banjar is now undergoing
have little to do with changes
in the broader political sphere.
Such is the opinion of Putu Suasta,
one of Bli's most frequently quoted
cultural and political commentators.
He believes that the banjar
has been changing long before
the Era of Reform was born. "Balinese
have been facing moral and cultural
modernisms for some time, and
have opted to incorporate many
elementso@ that 'newness' into
their everyday lives, thus bearing
forth a whole new set of Balinese
values," he says. Contemporary
Balinese values, Suasta points
out, include the incorporation
of modern infrastructure and management
styles which can generally be
referred to as the 'globalisation'
of the banjar. "There's
no need to fear that the banjar
is going to change its role
as a traditional institution.
Any changes instituted by a banjar
are most often only those
necessary to keep up with the
times."
Overcoming
statis in the banjar, according
to Putu Suasta, is a matter of
adopting new management systems.
"The banjar is like
any organisation. - changing it
is only a matter of management.
Nowadays, professional management
systems are a must for any organisation
that wants to progress, even of
that organisation is a so-called
traditional one, says Suasta.
But,
Suasta continues, the kind of
management style adopted needs
to be in keeping with the particular
conditions of a given banjar,
its human resources, its economic
situation and its geographic location.
"To date there's never been
a banjar which has had
to disband itself. The problem
facing the banjar is not
whether it can continue to exist
or not, but how to adapt to broader
changes taking place."
It
tends to be those banjars with
the foresight to institute necessary
change that end up retaining their
independence. "I have no
problem with banjars establishing
their own banks, minimarkets,
co-operatives or making use of
communal banjar land for
shipping centres or markets. it
is these kinds of economic initiatives
that can keep banjars and
their members from becoming dependent
on government resources,"
says Suasta.
For
the banjar itself, it is
hardly a matter of being dragged
kicking and screaming into the
future unknown. The majority welcome
change with the eagerness of a
sprinter at the starting block,
even Gianyar's Bukit Jangkrik,
which is about as far'in the sticks'
as one can get, so to speak. According
to its kelian dinas, 1
Made Supraptha, improvement of
public roads and the community
hall, the establishment of a village
co-operative, and increasing banjar
funds top the list of his constituent's
demands.
Many
banjars, both rural and urban,
have been exhibiting their eagerness
to change. The most obvious examples
are banjars located in
Denpasar. Most obvious because
it is banjars in Denpasar
that initiated a trend in'rehabilitating'
the banjar building - a
measure which has not recieved
unanimous support. In spite of
his fervour for renewal of lie
banjar, ecturer in Balinese
culture at Denpasar's Udayana
University, Windhu Sancaya, for
example, admits that he is less
enthusiastic about the drastic
measures some banjars have
gone to to 'rehabilitate' their
community halls. "This could
easily have the effect of undermining
the communal nuances of the banjar
space.
Many
people confess that they are hesitant
to continue using 'rehabilitated'
banjar halls that are now
complete with marble floors and
such, for traditional activities
such as childrens games, trading
traditional Balinese snacks, and
cock-fights.
While
some sources believe that adaptation
to globalisation is the primary
challenge currently facing the
banjar others see the reclaiming
of autonomy as the main reform
program at the banjar level.
That the banjar has the
capacity to welcome new values
is a fact of which Drs Ida Bagus
Pandjaja, the Head of Bali's Cultural
Unit, is convinced. "We can't
deny that modernity and globalisation
are facts of life in Bali. But
1 have no fear that this will
.-result in the disappearance
of traditional values. The banjar,
system is too strong to be
destroyed by modernisation,"
asserts Pandjaja. But what does
concern Pandjaja is the lack of
clarity in the way the banjar
is structured which, he believes,
has the potential to intrude on
the autonomy of the banjar,.
Pandjaja believes that the
affairs of many banjars are
dominated by administrative matters
of state, rather than serving
the interests of their members.
"The banjar should
ideally be an autonomous body,
not a branch of the subdistrict
administrative office. That means
that nobody, not even the government,
should be able to intervene in
the affairs of the banjar,.
It is the responsiblity of
the banjar., therefore.
to educate its members about principles
of autonomy and self determination,"
says Pandjaja.
Similarly,
according to Windhu Sancaya, it
is not enough for the banjar
to "simply exist. There
is widespread eagerness for traditional
institutions to be strengthened
vis-a-vis the central state. The
only problem is the lack of consensus
on what kind of new system will
serve to strengthen such institutions."
Sancaya
goes on to say that one of the
most vital ways in which the banjar,
needs to change is to cease
allow itself to be 'acted upon'
and start becoming a more pro-active
institution. "New morals
and values are increasingly being
applied to the lifestyles of the
Balinese, and much of this is
due to globalizations. As a traditional
institution, the banjar needs
to actively respond to such changes,
if it is not to be effortlessly
molded at will by the powers that
be." Ketu Sumarta, editor
of the Denpasar based daily Nusa
Tenggara, believes that
the autonomy of the banjar
has been proudly undermined during
the the New Order period (1966
- 1998, ed.) "Clearly, this
places a burden on the banjar.
And it is one of the primary
problems a banjar faces
in determining its priorities
and continued existence into the
future," he asserts. In other
words, according to Sumarta, the
greatest challenge facing the
banjar is not the entry
of global values to Bali, but
intervention of the state itself,
a fact which has been particularly
evident in the New Order period.
"The Balinese have been managing
the challenge posed by the entry
of so-called foreign values for
decades, and with great skill.
The proof of this is that globalization
has detracted little from the
resilience of Balinese traditions.
But state intervention poses an
altogether different and new challenge,"
says Sumarta.
SOLUTIONS
Physical
improvements to the banjar,
such as rehabilitating the
banjar hall, adding extra
storey to it and renting out the
bottom floor for commercial purposes
is, according to Pandjaja, one
of the ways the banjars can
utilize the assets at its disposal
in the interests of taking greater
control of its destiny. "As
long as those banjar activities
which are of primary importance
continue as usual, such as ngayah
(communal work bees), mebat
(communal rituals where offerings
are devoted to the Gods and the
resulting produce divided up amongst
banjar members), and paruman
(meetings of the committee
of banjar officials)", says
P'andjaja.
But according
to Ketut Sumarta, once a banjar
begins to prioritize economic
activities, its purpose changes
from one of a socio-religious
institution to a socioeconomic
one. Such a shift is to a certain
extent unavoidable given the ubiquity
of global capitalism, and the
importance of one of its biggest
industries tourism - to Bali's
economy. But what happens when
capitalism, too, fails? "Balinese
should not be too concerned considering
that our religious traditions
have a long history of a strong
social and economic basis,"
argues Sumarta. "It's only
natural that the activities prioritized
by the banjar are changing.
Capitalism has changed the lifestyles
of all Balinese. It's even got
to the point where religion has
become subject to economic considerations."
Indeed
traditionally, the activities
of the banjar have included
economic ones, such as money lending
co-operatives. and the subak
system. "But the traditional
understanding of banjar economic
activities was that they be for
the common good, not for individualistic
gain," says Sumarta. He suggests
that banjars that want
to continue to exist into the
future should prioritize the teaching
of Balinese script, and the philosophy
inherent within that script, to
their members. "The banjar
should take more of a role
in reminding the middle classes
of the importance of synchronizing
traditional and global values
into a new, Balinese value system.
It's unfortunate that much of
the Balinese middle class tend
to consider traditional values
as passely he laments.
According
to Ida Bagus Pandjaja, of foremost
importance to the banjar in
meeting the third milleneurn is
the recognition of it by all parties
as an independent and autonomous
traditional institution. It is
only in this way that the banjar
will have the capacity to
nurture and preserve Balinese
culture. "We have to remember
that the banjars are the
roots of Balinese culture."
Pandjaja wants to the banjar
return to its original function,
that is as a cultural centre for
its members. In this way, it is
at the banjar that children
can learn menggambel (to
play Balinese gamelan music.)
"Becoming a kind of cultural
centre is a way for the banjar
both to strengthen its institutions
base and to prepare itself for
the changes it will have to face.
It will ensure the continuity
of the banjar from generation
to generation," says Pandjaja.
On this note, he expresses hope
that the banjar youth will
in the future become more aggressive
in developing and nurturing traditional
values via the activities of the
STT.
BANJAR
YOUTH
But
what can really be expected of
the banjar youth groups? Anak
Agung Anom Mayun, former head
of Belaluan Samerta STT claims
that, based on his experience
as a banjar, youth official,
there is in fact little room for
the youth to play a role within
the banjar. "Most
young people are busy with their
own activities outside of the
banjar, like attending
university or working," he
explains. Similarly, according
to Nyoman joniarsa, a former head
of Bukit Jangkrik STT: "Our
committee made efforts to get
some worthwhile programs going,
like improving our management
capacity, making a community newsletter,
planning a village library and
obtaining scholarships for our
members who do particularly well
in school. But may of our members
aren't even attending school,
and if they do so its usually
only to primary school level or
at the most to junior high school.
That's not really a level of education
that serves as the basis for progress.
So it's not surprising that when
we finished our term. no-one wanted
to continue the programs we had
initiated."
Even
during these times when many hope
for a more open future, Bali's
official youth groups, it seems,
aspire to little. But few Balinese
fear that this spells the end
of the banjar. The banjar
will live on even if it fails
to resolve a dilemma that is as
universal as it is real to Balinese
communities: how to remain adaptive
and flexible without renouncing
one's independence?
Next
Page >> |